FEW THINGS get Donald Trump extra excited than speaking about transgender issues. As he delivers his closing argument to America, barely a speech or advert goes by and not using a point out of “unlawful aliens” getting “taxpayer-funded surgical procedure” or organic males competing in girls’s sports activities. Most of it’s inflammatory and hateful. A few of it’s clearly unfaithful, corresponding to his claims that kids are getting back from faculty with intercourse modifications, or his running-mate, J.D. Vance, suggesting this week that teenagers are “turning into trans” to get into Ivy League faculties. However a few of it’s not.
When requested just lately how he would handle the sports activities state of affairs, Mr Trump stated this was “such a straightforward query”: he would merely ban it. That introduced loud cheers from the all-female Fox viewers. It’s a message Republicans are emphasising up and down the poll. Latest polling by YouGov reveals that Trump supporters have larger consciousness of the previous president’s coverage on girls’s sports activities than of his coverage on abortion. In his ultimate days of campaigning, Mr Trump is spending extra on adverts that assault Kamala Harris’s assist for transgender rights than on another topic, based on Politico.
It’s simple to see why. Most People favour primary protections for transgender folks—towards hate speech, for instance, or discrimination at work—and imagine transgender folks must be handled with respect (see chart). But most agree with Mr Trump that some insurance policies and practices, nonetheless uncommon, have gone too far. Solely 19% of People, together with 33% of Democrats, assist the thought of trans athletes taking part in on the sports activities crew that matches their gender identification quite than their organic intercourse, based on YouGov. Certainly 25 states now require transgender college students to take part in sports activities primarily based on their natal intercourse, for causes of each security and equity. Solely 30% of People imagine prisons must be required to accommodate transgender inmates based on their gender identification. And simply 19% imagine transgender youths ought to have entry to puberty-blocking medicine (27% are uncertain and 54% are opposed).
All of those insurance policies are related to Democrats, both as a result of they supported them in the past or as a result of they’ve did not acknowledge among the sensible tensions that include slogans like “transwomen are girls”. Throughout her presidential marketing campaign, Ms Harris’s technique has been to keep away from the T-word in any respect prices, pivoting as an alternative to the safer floor of same-sex marriage or girls’s reproductive rights. Whereas the Republican Celebration’s conference was filled with (inflammatory) references to threats posed by trans folks, together with some remarks by Mr Trump’s two eldest sons, solely two audio system on the Democratic conference talked about trans folks, neither of them in a primetime slot.
Ms Harris’s silence has left house for Mr Trump to fill with footage of her earlier commitments (eg, to trans prisoners having the ability to get gender-affirming therapies) and with claims that, as a well-liked Republican advert concludes, “Loopy liberal Kamala is for they/them. President Trump is for you.” It appears to be resonating. In keeping with new polling by The Economist/YouGov, regardless of her vow of silence, some 36% of People assume Ms Harris talks about trans points an excessive amount of, in contrast with 23% who say the identical about Mr Trump.
However will it matter?
Republicans hope that outrage over what Mr Trump calls “trans madness” might be their model of what abortion has achieved for Democrats, however there’s a essential distinction. Whereas many People say abortion is a number one cause to vote, few say the identical about trans points. Polling reveals that social points normally function low on Trump voters’ precedence checklist, and inside social points transgender well being care (albeit an imperfect proxy) sits on the very backside. Mr Trump’s traces clearly play properly along with his base, and are a sure-fire means of getting a rally viewers to its toes, however there may be little proof that this particular concern will recruit many new voters (although Republican strategists declare it may possibly assist swing undecided voters, who might show essential).
Solely Ms Harris is aware of whether or not her latest silence is only a ruse till she is elected or whether or not she has genuinely moderated her stance. If elected, one alternative to indicate herself as extra in contact with the voters will come when her administration offers with probably the most controversial a part of Title IX anti-discrimination protections that the Biden administration kicked down the street: tips on how to take care of girls’s sports activities. By then she is perhaps able to agree along with her opponent on one matter: it’s a straightforward query. ■
