The occasions of the previous yr have radically altered Europe’s power coverage. The aim of attaining internet zero earlier than 2050, confirmed 12 months in the past on the COP26 assembly in Glasgow, continues to be in place. However the rapid precedence throughout Europe, now, is to safe power provides for the approaching winter and to mitigate the financial and social influence of dramatic will increase in oil and gasoline costs.
The short-term responses — extensions of the usage of coal and the seek for new native and imported sources of pure gasoline — may recommend that the local weather agenda set in Glasgow has been deserted. Nevertheless, that isn’t the case. If something, power is now a way more rapid political concern than it was a yr in the past.
The energy crisis sparked by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has definitely supplied a pointy reminder to European customers, and governments, that hydrocarbons nonetheless present greater than 80 per cent of the continent’s power wants.
However the sudden flip of occasions has additionally made the dangers of reliance on hydrocarbon imports manifestly evident. Consequently, the prospect of shifting to low-carbon sources of provide has turn out to be extra enticing.
Wind and photo voltaic are, for now a minimum of, each cheaper suppliers of electrical energy than imported gasoline. Utilizing energy produced regionally additionally reduces the discomfort of dependence on unreliable buying and selling companions. The power transition and the reason for power safety have merged into one.
Not surprisingly, the expansion of funding in wind and photo voltaic provides of electrical energy is the dominant development.
Beforehand seen as a “bridge” to a decrease carbon economic system — as it’s a much less polluting fossil gasoline than coal and oil — gasoline is considered the principal supply of power insecurity and has turn out to be the first goal of the transition agenda.
Demand for it can’t be eradicated shortly as a result of the infrastructure of power consumption from residence heating techniques to industrial crops is entrenched. Even so, complete consumption has fallen. Within the second quarter of this yr, Europe used 16 per cent much less pure gasoline than a yr earlier. That degree is about to fall additional.
Within the brief time period, new LNG services being constructed within the US and the Center East will present further provides to fill the rapid hole. However, in a shrinking market, Russia will wrestle to regain its dominant position as a provider even when the warfare in Ukraine ends quickly.
Extra tales from this report
A brand new, decrease carbon power combine is due to this fact rising in Europe — however at some value to the broader ambitions of the COP26 agenda. The urgency of the scenario over the previous six months has led to a reassertion of nationwide management of power coverage. Governments liable to be judged by their skill to maintain the lights on and to guard customers from hovering costs can not afford to attend for consensus throughout 28 international locations, not to mention for a worldwide deal.
Proposals from the European Fee for worth caps and customary buying preparations have been hindered by the necessity to transfer on the tempo of essentially the most reluctant member state. In Germany, specifically, nationwide help packages — securing provides and defending customers with worth subsidies — have transcended efforts to search out pan-European options.
The main target of nationwide insurance policies is inside and the associated fee is excessive. Because of Covid and power help packages, authorities debt throughout the EU has risen to over 90 per cent of GDP — and might be pushed larger by new packages being put in place. Rising bond charges are including to the prices of servicing the borrowing. In a local weather characterised by inflation and austerity, there may be little prospect of any severe response to the cries from rising economies for local weather justice. Nor, too, can we count on a rush to supply the brand new funding for power transition on the planet’s poorer international locations that might be demanded at COP27 in Sharm el-Sheikh.
The temper in Europe is one among protectionism — a dedication to guard Europe’s industrial base from the dangers of excessive power prices and provide interruptions. The levers of this protectionism vary from the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, which can put tariffs on imports from international locations not assembly European local weather requirements, to maximising regionally produced power provides — which, within the brief time period, will embody fossil fuels.
A interval of low financial development or, in some international locations, recession, can solely reinforce the development. This strategy might set off an open commerce battle with international locations akin to India, which resents Europe’s unwillingness to simply accept that rising economies nonetheless produce far fewer emissions per capita than the EU. And such conflicts, sadly, will hinder makes an attempt to achieve new and tighter agreements on the local weather agenda.
The excellent news is that Europe will most likely decrease its emissions extra quickly than might have been anticipated a yr in the past. The dangerous information is that, for the second, little progress is probably going on international offers.
Local weather coverage stays an essential focus for leaders throughout the continent. Optimists can solely hope that, as soon as financial stability is restored, they’ll realise that delivering a clear Europe in a unclean world achieves nothing.
The writer is visiting professor and former chair of the Kings Coverage Institute at King’s School London
Local weather Capital
The place local weather change meets enterprise, markets and politics. Explore the FT’s coverage here.
Are you interested in the FT’s environmental sustainability commitments? Find out more about our science-based targets here
